Rewardful vs Tolt vs FirstPromoter
Which affiliate platform is right for your SaaS? We compare features, pricing, and integrations — then show you a third option.
Quick Comparison
Rewardful
From $49/mo (up to 9% transaction fees)
Strengths
- Clean modern UI, fast setup
- Strong Stripe integration
- Solid documentation
- Affiliate portal included
Weaknesses
- Stripe-only
- Up to 9% transaction fees on lower plans
- Revenue caps on lower tiers
- External portal, no embedded widget
Tolt
From $47/mo + 2.9% transaction fees
Strengths
- Lowest entry price of the three
- Self-serve, fast setup
- Embeddable widget with custom domain
- Stripe + Paddle support
Weaknesses
- 2.9% + $0.30 transaction fees per conversion
- Revenue caps per plan tier
- Limited advanced features
- Auto payouts only on Growth tier and above
FirstPromoter
From $99/mo
Strengths
- Multiple payment provider support
- Strong fraud detection
- No transaction fees
- Mature feature set
Weaknesses
- Highest entry price of the three ($99/mo)
- Complex setup for small teams
- External affiliate dashboard
- Revenue limits on lower tiers
Consider a third option: Refgrow
Rewardful, Tolt, and FirstPromoter each have their merits, but Refgrow solves the limitations of each.
$29/mo, 0% fees
More affordable than both. No transaction fees, no revenue limits, no enterprise contracts.
Embedded widget
Unlike Rewardful, Tolt, and FirstPromoter, Refgrow embeds directly inside your product. No external portals.
5 payment providers
Stripe, Paddle, LemonSqueezy, Polar, and Dodo Payments — more than either competitor.
No credit card required
Frequently Asked Questions
Which is cheapest at small scale?
Tolt at $47/mo, but its 2.9% transaction fee adds up. Rewardful at $49 with up to 9% fees is the most expensive once volume picks up. FirstPromoter at $99 with 0% fees becomes the cheapest above ~$5K/mo affiliate revenue.
Which supports the most billing providers?
FirstPromoter (Stripe, Paddle, others). Tolt supports Stripe + Paddle. Rewardful is Stripe-only.
Which is most feature-rich?
FirstPromoter, especially around fraud detection and multi-tier. Rewardful is mid-tier. Tolt is the simplest of the three.
Do any of these embed in your app?
Tolt offers an embeddable widget with custom-domain support; Rewardful and FirstPromoter use external portals.
Ready to try a better alternative?
Launch your affiliate program in under 5 minutes with Refgrow.
Start your 14-day free trial →No credit card required • Cancel anytime